Pseudo-productivity is killing the NHS

A lot of things done for the NHS do not help people get healthier. It is easy to get lost in the weeds arguing about what healthier means or whether it should be a public good. But let’s take the simple definition of “living longer and having more fun” and go with that. Some stuff … Read more

Why are they using Physician Associates to de-professionalise medicine?

A profession is where the public is protected against charlatans by only letting people with specific training do certain things. In medicine this used to include only allowing doctors to prescribe, operate, anaesthetise or make referrals. But in many countries these rules are being relaxed, and less knowledgeable staff are being given these roles. Why … Read more

Why are they replacing Doctors with Physician Associates?

Doctors in the UK, USA, India and Australia have commented about finding their roles being taken by much less trained and knowledgeable clinicians. Have the medical educators suddenly realised that all their efforts were in vain? Is medicine actually easy enough for a science graduate to pick it up in two years? Or is something … Read more

Does the Government want GPs to “Do a Dentist” and become private?

Lacobucci reports the NHSE has been “listening closely to the views of the profession and patients”[1]. So it is hard to understand why they are only offering GPs 2.2% inflation funding when inflation is 4.2%[2]. Especially when there is a shortage of GPs and patients cannot get appointments[3]. The Government are not idiots and must … Read more

Are doctors any good compared to the alternatives?

… is a better question than “Do we still really need doctors?” A common trend throughout the NHS recently has been the replacement of doctors with cheaper staff. This is universally assumed to reduce the costs of care with little or no long-term evidence. In General Practice, which is notoriously cost sensitive because costs affect … Read more

Wes Streeting wants to ditch NHS rose-tinted nostalgia without realising that Partnership General Practice is a super evolved species of healthcare

There is a narrative in UK politics and media that General Practice is somehow stuck in some analogue past from Dr Finlay’s Casebook. However, the reality couldn’t be more different. Because GP partnerships are owned and run by the doctors who work in them, they have become as diverse as the communities they care for. … Read more