Why are they using Physician Associates to de-professionalise medicine?

A profession is where the public is protected against charlatans by only letting people with specific training do certain things. In medicine this used to include only allowing doctors to prescribe, operate, anaesthetise or make referrals. But in many countries these rules are being relaxed, and less knowledgeable staff are being given these roles.

Why is this happening? Have we suddenly discovered you don’t need a 5-year medical degree and several years of postgraduate training to be safe doing these tasks? Does replacing doctors with the same spend on Physician Associates give better outcomes? In fact, employing doctors appears to be more clinically and cost effective (1).

Over the past 30 years medicine has been invaded by corporate business ideas (2). These work well in manufacturing, retail and service industries but cope poorly with highly knowledgeable, articulate, motivated, stubborn, and irreplaceable frontline staff. Doctors have power due to their professional privileges, but central management may be replacing them with more obedient Physician Associates to gain more control.

Is this a good idea? Would patients get better health (or a quicker return to best achievable health) if doctors’ professional roles were given to Physician Associates? The trials of these new ways of working are all designed to succeed and get extra funding. None of them compare like for like with current doctor-led services on the same budget to see which is better.

And that’s the problem. The industry managers who have taken over healthcare are certain they know what is needed. They have successfully run other businesses, so they feel on solid ground. But they don’t realise that they are in different territory with healthcare and should conduct properly designed experiments. What they “know” to be true is really just a bet. And we are the ones that pay if they’re wrong.

The medical profession has evolved a system for looking after people that works. We should be open to trying new things to see if they are better. But it is crucial that we set the ultimate goal against which we measure success. The long-term health of our communities has to come above quarterly profits, shareholder value or electoral votes.

This is not an attack on Physician Associates. They have skills and training which can help patients. But, for political reasons, they are being encouraged to take on roles for which the current evidence suggests they are not the best clinicians. And that is unfair to them and to their patients.

1) https://www.ama-assn.org/practice-management/scope-practice/amid-doctor-shortage-nps-and-pas-seemed-fix-data-s-nope
2) https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/healthcare/our-insights/the-future-of-healthcare-value-creation-through-next-generation-business-models