Pseudo-productivity is killing the NHS

A lot of things done for the NHS do not help people get healthier. It is easy to get lost in the weeds arguing about what healthier means or whether it should be a public good. But let’s take the simple definition of “living longer and having more fun” and go with that.

Some stuff is obvious useful: a surgeon operating on a broken hip; a physician diagnosing and treating cancer; a therapist helping depression. But other things, not so much: writing reports that no-one reads; booking appointments just to meet targets; unnecessary investigations by inexperienced clinicians.

The problem is that measuring actual benefit is hard, messy, and subtle. So, it is easier to count reports, appointments, and investigations as a proxy for achievement. Worse still, politicians find it easier and cheaper to win votes by pointing to activity rather than truly making people’s lives better.

But for patients, true productivity is all that counts. Wasting effort on things that don’t help means they get less of what they need. Good management helps clinicians spend more of their time treating patients. Bad management wastes clinician time doing pseudo-productive admin.

There are two kinds of patient demand: hard demand for things like cancer and heart disease that will not go away until it is treated; and soft demand for self-limiting conditions like sore throats and minor infections that will get better without treatment.

Treating soft demand is also pseudo-productivity because it doesn’t change the outcome and it has a cost. Paying a pharmacist or physician assistant to see a patient with a self-limiting illness is a waste of money.

Organising clinicians to look after a population, rather than paying them per consultation, encourages them to focus on hard demand because that will persist whereas soft demand will fix itself.

People say we can’t afford the NHS because there isn’t enough money. But, although more money will help, the reality is that our talent and resources are being wasted on things which don’t improve long-term outcomes.

And better long-term outcomes for patients are the reason the NHS exists.